Top Rated Stories in category:
Gay Male
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 51. | My Baseball Buddy My new neighbor invited me over to watch baseball, and... by AtlantisGuy (04/18/24) | 4.82 (399) |
| 52. | Against All Odds Ch. 09 Noah and Riley grow closer. by Chancem77 (04/23/24) | 4.82 (38) |
| 53. | A Summer at the Farm Ch. 16 Blake loses his anal virginity with a HUGE monster-cock! by Thomas_Lodge (04/21/24) | 4.81 (216) |
| 54. | The Guy Next Door David crushes on his new neighbour. by Secretauthor2021 (04/18/24) | 4.81 (81) |
| 55. | My Gay Harem of Hot Brothers Pt. 03 High school twink needs a bed. by SummerSammy (05/09/24) | 4.81 (54) |
| 56. | A Summer at the Farm Ch. 20 Muscle hunk farmer daddy goes submissive! by Thomas_Lodge (05/12/24) | 4.81 (91) |
| 57. | College Days Pt. 06 Danny and Phil wake up. by WillSuckYou (05/08/24) | 4.81 (21) |
| 58. | Gym Idol Ch. 01 A straight, skinny guy is obsessed with massive bodybuilder. by CocksAndMuscles (04/25/24) | 4.81 (261) |
| 59. | Phil & Connor Pt. 03 - Fishing Trip It's the end of the season and Connor, with Phil, go fishing. by DoughallDeeson (05/05/24) | 4.81 (26) |
| 60. | Video Night with David Ch. 03 The third part of the story of my time with David. by Mydnyter (04/21/24) | 4.80 (25) |
| 61. | Brief Encounters Ch. 07 A thief breaks into his bully's home to find a secret. by Bjsroxxs (04/25/24) | 4.80 (25) |
| 62. | Kevin the Gardener Pt. 01A - Caterer What happened with the caterer - find out. by DoughallDeeson (05/12/24) | 4.80 (25) |
| 63. | Community Gym Getting an anal workout at the community gym. by Waltron (05/08/24) | 4.79 (187) |
| 64. | What Happened at the Party Ch. 02 Glenn turns up on Mark's doorstep again, but is he sober? by ThisOldGuy (05/12/24) | 4.79 (43) |
| 65. | Big Mack Pt. 02 The mechanic and the emo hook up again. by flatiron2 (04/18/24) | 4.79 (38) |
| 66. | A Husband's Legal Consent Ch. 03 Brett and David continued their fuck-a-thon. by AmoriferXi (04/24/24) | 4.79 (19) |
| 67. | The boys of Saint Augustine’s Welcome to Saint Augustine’s school for boys. by Secretauthor2021 (05/05/24) | 4.78 (88) |
| 68. | Used by Backpacking Frat Bros Pt. 02 Nick goes back to Josh's tent. by jtwy (04/30/24) | 4.78 (189) |
| 69. | What Happened at the Party Ch. 01 Mark has a surprise encounter at the Christmas party. by ThisOldGuy (04/22/24) | 4.78 (183) |
| 70. | Good Cop Bad Cop Two dominant daddy cops pull over an unsuspecting twink. by Subotter4beardaddy (05/10/24) | 4.77 (106) |
| 71. | The Uncut Club Two roommates find themselves joining a club. by LongSkinDrip (05/17/24) | 4.77 (22) |
| 72. | A Summer at the Farm Ch. 19 Clearly, Blake is no longer straight. Right? by Thomas_Lodge (05/08/24) | 4.77 (135) |
| 73. | Neighborly A friendly offer turns into an unforgettable threesome. by SexyInMy60s (05/05/24) | 4.77 (216) |
| 74. | Hypno Project Ch. 07 Ian helps Nick. by joog (04/21/24) | 4.76 (59) |
| 75. | Chapter 2: Kiss and Tell No One Matt has an unusual hookup. by JackChandler (04/21/24) | 4.75 (84) |
| 76. | After the End Ch. 19 All-male triad explore intimacy and passion. by RobinZephyr (05/13/24) | 4.75 (16) |
| 77. | A Doctor and his Spy Ch. 05 Lovers recover and remember their Sexapade on park bench. by 4mnowhere (05/15/24) | 4.75 (8) |
| 78. | Used by Backpacking Frat Bros Pt. 04 Patrick has an eye-opening experience. by jtwy (05/16/24) | 4.74 (73) |
| 79. | Used by Backpacking Frat Bros Pt. 03 Patrick realizes what Nick's done with Josh. by jtwy (05/07/24) | 4.74 (133) |
| 80. | Teammates Pt. 02 Baseball jocks take a midnight swim. by hellocapybara (05/16/24) | 4.73 (67) |
| 81. | First Time Lasted a Second Inning Gay Male Sexual Exploration. by Tommyknocker703 (05/15/24) | 4.73 (52) |
| 82. | Demonic Dice Transformations Urban-fantasy-type transformations, complete story. by RichardButtstuff (04/25/24) | 4.73 (22) |
| 83. | Country Singer Pt. 01 - Encounter When my country singer crush moved to town. by DoughallDeeson (05/02/24) | 4.72 (80) |
| 84. | Perfection Who wants perfect? That would be boring. by emilyagilbert (05/11/24) | 4.72 (18) |
| 85. | The Roommate Arrangement - Pt. 01 Bran makes an offer his straight roommate can't refuse. by Saltedmabel (04/21/24) | 4.72 (355) |
| 86. | Straight Vegas Nights Carson's bachelor party takes a turn with his best bud. by Grayson87 (04/28/24) | 4.72 (177) |
| 87. | London Student Rent Boy Older man pays a young student for sex. by Daniel6700044 (05/06/24) | 4.71 (126) |
| 88. | Big Mack Pt. 04 The emo craved more blue-collar dick. by flatiron2 (05/11/24) | 4.71 (21) |
| 89. | Rory and Philip Ch. 03 Rory and Philip - friends with benefits. by spiritseeker561 (04/21/24) | 4.71 (14) |
| 90. | Gloryhole First Time Pt. 02 First Gloryhole Visit Continues. by sftopbottom (05/10/24) | 4.71 (132) |
| 91. | I Blame Basketball Ch. 02 Giving head to J. again and a surprise. by ragal2 (05/05/24) | 4.71 (106) |
| 92. | Becoming a Woman in Prison Ch. 02 Clarissa sees Dixie please the entire gang. by sexyfloridaboy (05/02/24) | 4.71 (68) |
| 93. | Mom's Sex Pills Ch. 01 Mom's medical mishap leads to gay sex for son and his BFF. by greenbriefs (05/03/24) | 4.70 (284) |
| 94. | Convention Cum Dump Married man gets the chance to make his fantasies real. by Shady_Lady (04/24/24) | 4.70 (175) |
| 95. | Chapter 6: Truth or Bare Matt's interview for membership in secret gay club on campus. by JackChandler (05/12/24) | 4.70 (47) |
| 96. | Late Night Gym Lockers Ch. 01 Late night workout + two muscular guys = the unexpected. by Sk8erboi89 (04/21/24) | 4.70 (114) |
| 97. | My Awakening Learning about myself. by highlycharged (05/12/24) | 4.70 (114) |
| 98. | Introducing My Friend to Gloryholes Ride home with best bud results in 1st gloryhole visit. by win69win (04/18/24) | 4.70 (191) |
| 99. | Cracking the Code Sometimes fixing computers leads to lots of fun. by CumStories (05/15/24) | 4.70 (157) |
| 100. | Room Mate Helps Out College boy tries oral sex for the first time. by MarkVA66 (05/15/24) | 4.70 (209) |
