Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 151. | Annette Annette's conservative ideals are challenged by her desires. by AshCardiff (11/29/23) | 4.66 (213) |
| 152. | My Big Titty Goth Roommate What's a little mutual face fucking between friends? by iwiwt (09/08/23) | 4.66 (437) |
| 153. | A Trip to Rome - Monday During a school trip a young girl has her first experiences. by Cougar77 (03/27/24) | 4.66 (64) |
| 154. | Good Girl Ch. 01: Discovery Sissy discovers herself with unexpected help from a friend. by SC_sissy (10/17/23) | 4.65 (295) |
| 155. | Life Model Swapping computer knowledge for modelling time - and more! by Frederick Carol (04/01/24) | 4.65 (248) |
| 156. | Nicole Qualley A high school senior finds illicit love with a teacher. by JohnMurray4173 (11/06/23) | 4.65 (124) |
| 157. | Fingered in the Dark Freya plays with a vibrator, then gets fingered. by FreyaGersemi (12/16/23) | 4.65 (161) |
| 158. | Auntie Liz An 18 year old virgin is tutored by his sexy auntie. by Smuttyandfun (11/07/23) | 4.65 (534) |
| 159. | Gabriela Andrews Teenager's antics attract the attention of her neighbour. by IV60 (12/25/23) | 4.65 (109) |
| 160. | The Barbecue Party Ch. 01 Asian MILF gets fucked by her son's best friend. by Egglime (08/04/23) | 4.65 (632) |
| 161. | A night of firsts A weekend birthday getaway, turns into an eye opening serie. by Shesasquirter (08/21/23) | 4.65 (170) |
| 162. | Nerd Becomes a Cumslut Ch. 04 Ashley is a nerd but she wants to be a cumslut. by ExtremelyAnonymous (03/28/24) | 4.65 (136) |
| 163. | Watching... Ch. 04 - Trying Something New Could a straight woman, enjoy licking pussy? by Shellyvan (06/09/23) | 4.64 (101) |
| 164. | Motel Summer Ch. 02: Housekeeping My motel summer; housekeeping is more than economics at home. by moveablefeast66 (02/08/24) | 4.64 (112) |
| 165. | The House Group Leader's Wife Pt. 04 Connor comes to the aid of two overseas students. by The_Veil_of_Isis (10/15/23) | 4.64 (28) |
| 166. | Amazon Erin Fucks a Virgin A voluptuous teen takes a boy's virginity at a wild party. by iggyspear (02/03/24) | 4.64 (257) |
| 167. | Work Experience A virgin young man is trained by his new boss. by Calorific (12/21/23) | 4.64 (618) |
| 168. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 06 Exploring fantasies with Julie. by JQueen9 (06/09/23) | 4.64 (204) |
| 169. | Audrey & Harry Ch. 01 Audrey & Harry face their biology teacher's 'punishment'. by Accipiter12 (11/14/23) | 4.64 (77) |
| 170. | Drive Babysitter loses virginity to the dad who drives her home. by rebelxcarpenter (03/02/24) | 4.63 (268) |
| 171. | The Suburban Mom Pt. 03 Marcia samples Croatian delicacies. by The_Veil_of_Isis (06/21/23) | 4.63 (175) |
| 172. | The Suburban Mom Pt. 02 The soccer mom is seduced by the babysitter. by The_Veil_of_Isis (06/17/23) | 4.63 (328) |
| 173. | Freya Loves Cock Freya and Alex enjoy their first time fucking. by FreyaGersemi (12/22/23) | 4.63 (164) |
| 174. | The Suburban Mom Pt. 08 Connor is tasked with proving he isn't racist. by The_Veil_of_Isis (07/09/23) | 4.63 (112) |
| 175. | A Game to Lose Laurel invites a trusted friend over for her first time. by amooseontheloose (09/06/23) | 4.63 (112) |
| 176. | The Missing Pilot WWII Land Girl and naval pilot are reunited on Valentine's. by mrs_mackenzie (01/20/24) | 4.63 (193) |
| 177. | Unexpected Interlude Jay and Lorraine introduce a young woman to lovemaking... by eroticcouplings (09/21/23) | 4.63 (38) |
| 178. | Taking Kevin's Cherry Pt. 02 Taking Kevin's last cherry. by groomleader (10/26/23) | 4.63 (65) |
| 179. | Living the Dream in Mexico Pt. 07 Valentina becomes a woman at last. by oldtruckdriver (05/28/23) | 4.63 (94) |
| 180. | Wednesday Evenings with Babs Pt. 03 Babs continues to rock my world. by secret_passion_49 (07/28/23) | 4.63 (51) |
| 181. | Charlotte's Tea Room Two people looking for something to share with one another. by letmebelast (11/11/23) | 4.63 (51) |
| 182. | Our First Time She overcomes her inhibitions and we enjoy each other. by SpartanWitherby (01/07/24) | 4.63 (289) |
| 183. | My Boring Commute Pt. 02 Chris buys Brittney some items by richbigpenis (11/25/23) | 4.62 (199) |
| 184. | Sandy Ch. 06 Come on in. by ktingram18 (02/29/24) | 4.62 (37) |
| 185. | The Need... A man finally gets the cock he’s always secretly wanted... by Godwulf (12/21/23) | 4.62 (219) |
| 186. | She keeps it in friend’s family Ch. 01 She has sex with female friend and friends father. by Satsumabook123 (08/17/23) | 4.62 (113) |
| 187. | Love with a Married Woman Ch. 02 Young man and married woman have their affair. by Sincerelyyours000 (08/27/23) | 4.62 (136) |
| 188. | Sophia's Choice Pt. 03 Ulf fixes Sophia's problem. by Alice_Nicol (06/20/23) | 4.62 (34) |
| 189. | Someone Who Actually Likes You Better someone who likes you than someone paid to like you. by DanDraper (11/04/23) | 4.62 (298) |
| 190. | Matty Scores a Hat-trick Fun and games for a quick learner. by gnomelander (03/03/24) | 4.62 (81) |
| 191. | Love is Being Stupid Together Ch. 03 Continued misbehavior by Nerd Kait and Geek Nick. by RicknCenFl (02/11/24) | 4.62 (60) |
| 192. | Glory at the Hole Pt. 02 Continuation of Glory's first time at the hole. by bigglebab (02/14/24) | 4.62 (203) |
| 193. | Almost Home 19yo Nikki's first ever 1 night stand with an older man. by SexHex (07/24/23) | 4.61 (165) |
| 194. | Sandy Ch. 04 A taste of things to cum. by ktingram18 (02/23/24) | 4.61 (72) |
| 195. | A Dating App Paid My New Lingerie! And how I experienced to be a hot Escort for the first time. by Chridi (10/17/23) | 4.61 (87) |
| 196. | Art is My Favorite Class Ch. 03 It's time for Sarah to be deflowered. by NaughtyPaladin (06/08/23) | 4.61 (263) |
| 197. | Runaway Fantasy Pt. 02 An older man teaches a teen girl everything about oral sex. by becca20S (08/26/23) | 4.61 (74) |
| 198. | Samantha and Barbara How I met the Mistress that changed my life. by mollycactus (11/09/23) | 4.61 (117) |
| 199. | Farm Girl Amy Pt. 08 The second blow job has an audience. by richbigpenis (11/06/23) | 4.61 (261) |
| 200. | Love is Being Stupid Together Ch. 04 Kait and Nick continue sexual exploration in Key Largo. by RicknCenFl (02/20/24) | 4.61 (38) |
