Mistaken Identity? Ch. 03

We stood there for what seemed like a long moment of silence. Kathleen dripping wet and naked with the towel on the floor in front of her. Sherry staring at her pussy. I knew Sherry had played the field before her marriage. She was loose, sleeping with various men and women. I only ever saw her flirt with a few women in the past, but seeing her stare at Kathleen's pussy, like that, was a definite turn-on for me.

Just at that moment, the doorbell rang. We all looked at one another in surprise.

"I'll get it. Whatever you do, don't get dressed." Sherry said while looking at Kathleen's slick nudity.

Kathleen walked over to me seductively, as Sherry exited the room, and ran down the stairs to answer the front door. Kathleen kissed me, and rubbed her naked body up against me. Before I knew what hit me, I had a rock-hard erection that needed attention. Kathleen rubbed her pussy up against it teasingly. We continued kissing as I wondered who it could be at the front door.

I heard Sherry talking to someone. It sounded like another woman, but I could faintly hear their voices as Kathleen traced my earlobe with her tongue. I heard Sherry and the other woman walk into another room as they continued to talk. I dismissed any thought of who it might be as Kathleen cupped my cock in her hands and rubbed it against her soft pussy.

We were about to consummate our sexual act when I heard footsteps on the stairs outside my room and Sherry quickly entered the room without knocking. She paused to watch us for a moment.

"You'll never guess who was at the door." She said in an excited voice.

"Who?" I asked.

"Your ex. The slut. Beth." Sherry said.

"What did she want?" I asked a little annoyed that Beth would come back after her actions.

My annoyance grew at her audacity. She always expected forgiveness no matter her actions or who it hurt.

"Well she wanted to talk to you. But first she wanted to apologize to me for sleeping with my soon-to-be-ex-husband." Sherry said as she folded her arms over her ample breasts.

"Is she gone?" I asked, knowing the answer.

Sherry shook her head "No." as I expected she would.

"Hmmmm, I have an idea. She wants to hang around, maybe we can punish her." I said thinking up my scheme.

"How?" Kathleen interjected.

I took a bottle off the nightstand next to my waterbed. I held it up.

"Two of these will do the trick. They will knock her out. Believe me I've seen her take them for a headache. She can barely handle one. Two will do the trick for sure. But first, I want to play a cruel trick on her for what she did. Here's the plan.........." I said as I continued on.

Sherry ran back downstairs with two of the pills that will dissolve in Beth's drink. Kathleen smiled at me and sat on the bed. I jumped on her, and kissed her, before quietly exiting the room.

I went into the other room where Sherry's husband was staying the night before, until we kicked him out this morning. I shut the blinds & curtains, making the room as dark as it would be during the daytime. I took off my boxers and lay down in the bed under the covers. I smelled Beth's perfume faintly reminding me what she had done during the night.

Not too long after I got in the bed I heard Sherry talking to Beth as they entered the stairway.

"I'm so sorry. I thought Mike was still sleeping in that room. I had no idea it was your husband." I heard Beth say.

"It's OK. We are separated anyway." Sherry said.

"Whoa, I feel dizzy." Beth said.

"Maybe you should go upstairs and lay down on a bed for awhile, until you feel better." Sherry said.

"What about Mike? I know he is mad about me and your husband." Beth said.

"Don't worry about him. I'll talk to Mike for you." Sherry said, as I could hear her helping Beth up the stairs slowly, like someone helping a drunk to walk up a flight of steps.

"Thanks. You are so nice." Beth said.

Little did she know, I laughed to myself internally.

"Here. It's the closest room. Just take a nap until you feel better." Sherry said opening the door of the room I was in.

I peaked up from under the covers and saw Sherry walking Beth in with her arms wrapped around her. Beth seemed so out of it that she wasn't even aware of my form on the bed. Sherry guided her to the bed next to me and Beth plopped down, still clothed in what she wore when she left this morning. Sherry winked at me and tip-toed to the closet and slipped in. She shut it most of the way, but left enough space so she could know when she was needed again.

Beth turned over in her partial sleep and her arm met my body. She seemed startled.

"Are you still here?" She whispered thinking I was Sherry's husband.

I nodded my head in the darkness.

"Sherry and Mike will kill us if they knew we were in bed together again." She whispered.

I lowered the covers and revealed my rock hard cock. She gasped. Luckily the rainy day was so dark it helped disguise me into just a shadowy form.

"I don't think we should be doing this again." She whispered in my ear.

I grabbed the back of her head and guided her down the bed until I felt her lips touch my cock. I grabbed my cock with the other hand and forced it into her mouth. She choked for a moment before she started sucking. After her momentary surprise, she seemed into sucking my cock (unlike when we dated) with eagerness. I thrust my cock up to her waiting mouth, fucking it as much as she was sucking me. I heard her moan and slurp on it, which I found sexy. I could see Sherry from the closet with her hands in her shorts playing with her pussy. I stared at her as Beth sucked me. I blew Sherry a kiss with just my lips as both my hands were busy on Beth's head.

I felt no resistance and looked down to see Beth had passed out sucking my cock. I figured "what the hell" and continued fucking her mouth as she was passed out. If she wouldn't swallow for me before, I wouldn't give her a choice now. I whispered for Sherry to come out of the closet and she did.

"Should we move her now?" Sherry whispered into my ear.

"No." I whispered back.

I kissed Sherry as her face was close to mine. She kissed me back passionately. Our tongues met and danced. I continued fucking Beth's mouth as Sherry moved down my body kissing my chest and stomach before stopping at Beth's head. She freed my hands from Beth's head and took over moving Beth up and down on my cock. It felt so fucking good. I saw Sherry licking her lips as she was turned on. She bent down and licked the parts of my cock that was not in Beth's mouth. She continued guiding Beth's head up and down on my cock as she pulled up Beth's shirt and played with her naked tits.

I found it sexy to be fucking Beth's mouth while she was unaware. Her mouth was wet and hot, but there was no sucking. Though the thought of filling her mouth with my cum, and making her swallow it, appealed to me and turned me on. It was partial payback for how much of a bitch she had been to me in our relationship, and afterward. The thought urged me on as I pounded her mouth. With Sherry's help we turned Beth over onto her back and I fucked her vulnerable mouth. Sherry held the exposed parts of my dick and played with my balls, making me even more excited.

I felt the urge to cum wash over me, as I didn't have to worry about holding back with Beth, for the first time. I let the cum erupt from my cock into her waiting mouth. The cum dripped right back out onto my cock as Beth coughed in her sleep. She was still out like a light. I laid there with Sherry watching me, ready to make a move when I was ready. I nodded at her.

We lifted Beth off the bed. I had her arms and Sherry had her legs. We carried her into my bedroom. Kathleen had the ropes all ready to go, when we plopped Beth down on my waterbed. Sherry and I worked to undress Beth. The ropes were tied to the wooden holes (for plugs, like alarm clocks) in the headboard. Sherry and Kathleen worked to tie up Beth's hands and make sure they were secure. Her feet were another matter entirely. We had to let them go and risk it. There was no place to tie them that was secure enough to hold her legs apart.

I looked at Sherry, who was now naked. Now all four of us were completely naked. Sherry looked down at Beth's pussy and licked her lips. She bent over and began licking Beth's pussy and fingering it. Kathleen and I stared at one another for a moment before returning our eyes to the unbelievable sight before us.

"Something tells me this isn't the first time Sherry ate a woman out." Kathleen whispered to me.

I nodded my head in agreement.

"Have you ever eaten a woman before?" I asked Kathleen.

"No, but I always wanted to give it a try." She said.

I motioned with my hand as Sherry was bent over doggy style while eating Beth's pussy. Kathleen licked her lips and dove in. She leaned down and started licking Sherry, who looked back in surprise, and then smiled. Despite Beth being unconscious she moaned as her body couldn't help but react to the pleasure Sherry was giving it. I shrugged my shoulders as I saw Kathleen bent over Sherry, who was bent over Beth.

I began licking and playing with Kathleen's pussy. My cock grew rock hard again and it needed a pussy. I pulled back from Kathleen, who seemed disappointed, until I rammed my cock all the way in her pussy. Sherry stopped eating Beth for a moment to lean back and watch me fuck Kathleen.

"That's so fucking hot!" Sherry whimpered, as Kathleen was still eating her pussy and Sherry was approaching an intense orgasm.

Sherry didn't miss a beat as she returned to eating Beth out. I slammed my cock in and out of Kathleen's pussy from behind, but the sight in front of me was too fantastic. I soon pulled out and sprayed my thick cum all over her ass. Sherry looked back again and she pulled away from Beth. She pulled away from Beth and crawled behind Kathleen. Sherry began licking all the cum off of Kathleen's ass. It was sexy seeing my two beautiful cousins in this sexual scenario. Kathleen moaned, as she replaced Sherry, and began eating Beth's pussy.

I thrust my cock into Sherry from behind, and began pounding her pussy. My balls slapping the underside of her pussy. She moaned as she licked Kathleen's pussy, but never pulled away. Beth's head began tossing side to side and she moaned. Her eyes began flickering as they finally opened.

"Oh my God!" She screamed loudly with her explosive orgasm.

It was like a chain reaction. Kathleen began whimpering and laid her head between Beth's legs as she screamed out with her orgasm. Sherry looked back at me as I picked up my pace, fucking her fast and furiously. My cock was literally slapping in and out of her pussy loudly as she moaned. Beth and Kathleen both watched us. Sherry screamed out with her orgasm, as I felt her pussy tighten on my cock. I shot stream, after stream, of my hot cum into her waiting pussy. We all collapsed on the bed in exhaustion.

It wasn't until Beth tried to move that she noticed she was tied up to the bed.

"What the hell is going on here?" She demanded.

"Payback time, bitch." I said coldly, she seemed struck by my comment and shut up.

I felt all the anger, and rage, build up in me at the things Beth has done over the years. Playing games with my mind, time and time again. interfering in my other relationships, and having a boyfriend after she messed my relationships up. It seemed more a game than her wanting me.

Sherry and Kathleen cleared the way as I crawled up between Beth's legs. Beth looked ready to resist, but I caught her off-guard with my quickness. I slammed into her pussy with my still hard cock roughly. She screamed in pain, but I didn't let it affect me. I thrust into her harshly. She moaned and tears flowed from her eyes. She kept moaning though, and despite resisting at first, she soon laid there and accepted her fate.

Kathleen and Sherry crawled up beside us and began licking her tits and sucking her nipples. Beth couldn't help but like this. She loved to have her tits sucked and licked. She stared at me in defiance, before her wall crumbled and she bit her lower lip. Yes, indeed, she was now enjoying this. I picked up my pace and felt an orgasm approaching. Hers was already starting when mine soon hit. I didn't pull out as she always wanted me to. Instead I flooded her pussy with my cum, and her eyes got big and round. She was completely shocked that I did this.

While I rested, Kathleen and Sherry untied Beth, and flipped her over doggy style, in front of me, and retied her hands to the headboard. Beth tried to fight them off, but they overpowered her, and outnumbered her. My cousins won the battle easily. I thrust my semi-hard cock back into her pussy, to soak up our juices, and then entered her tight asshole. She screamed in pain, and cried loudly, but I kept repeating my actions, until her ass was well lubricated. The tightness of her ass and her clenching up made it very tight, and exciting, because she didn't want this even more than she didn't want me to cum in her pussy, or mouth.

I began fucking her ass as she begged me to stop.

"Please, Mike! Don't do this! I'm sorry for fucking Sherry's husband!" She pleaded.

Sherry laughed, and I slapped Beth's ass roughly causing her to wince in pain.

"You going to be a good girl and shut up, or do you want more of this?" I asked.

"Please, don't!" She cried.

I slapped her other asscheek harder than the original and she cried louder. I began thrusting into her ass harder, breaking her resistance and causing her asshole to loosen up. One thing is for sure, before today her asshole was never fucked. Now it was being broken wide open. I spread her asscheeks as I thrust in and out at a good pace. I kept it slower than when I fucked her pussy. I wanted her to be taught a lesson.

I grabbed her hanging tits and molded them to my hands. I pulled on her nipples hard and she moaned. Her head soon hung in acceptance of her fate. She no longer fought me, but still didn't seem to like the fucking I gave her ass. I picked up the pace as I felt my cum approaching the head of my cock. I let the first few jets go into her ass, before pulling out. I quickly went up to her head, where Kathleen and Sherry held her head to the side, and forced her mouth open and unleashed the last streams of my cum to enter her mouth.

"Now, I think we are even. What do you say, slut?" I asked Beth.

"Do you think we can do this again sometime?" Beth asked, shocking us all, as she partially smiled with how horny she was.