• Home
  • /
  • Stories Hub
  • /
  • Group Sex
  • /
  • The Good Ones Are Always Bad

The Good Ones Are Always Bad

Jen was first acquainted with Colin and Wade on meeting them at Colin's parents' lake house in southern Wisconsin. But she was always too nervous to say more than a few words to them. She thought they both were so cute, so mysterious, and she longed to share their company devoid of the immobilizing nervousness they provoked in her.

But what she did not know was that they longed for her company as much as she did theirs, and, while her longing was quite more innocent, theirs was perverted, and they meant to act on it all too soon.

Aside from being the lake house neighbors, Jen's parents' house was about an hour and a half drive from Colin and Wade's hometown. They were anticipating a trip to see Jen one of these nights. Jen, a Christian girl, had never had sex before, a tight and petite young blonde whose virginity and innocence were especial turn-ons for Colin and Wade; she was saving herself for Jamie, her boyfriend, whom she planned to marry after college. Colin and Wade had both had regular girlfriends, had had sex plenty of times between the two of them, but were fascinated with the idea of sharing a girl between the two of them. They decided between themselves to cheat on both of their girlfriends—"They'd never know," they told each other. "Besides, Jen thinks we're both single. The only trouble is convincing her to cheat on Jamie." They thought that Jamie was such a "pussy," that Jen needed to experience real men. And they were ready to give it to her. She was going to get the double stuff.

They decided that they'd surprise her, and each of them told their respective parents' that they'd be spending the night at the other's house, so as not to draw suspicion on their absence that night. They wouldn't be returning until the morning. It was going to definitely be an all-nighter, they decided.

"Hey, come to the mall," Colin texted Jen some time that afternoon, when they had just arrived. "Meet us by the food court.

Jen complied, eager to see her old friends. When she got their, Colin and Wade exchanged lustful glances, examining Jen in all her glory; she was wearing tight blue jeans that left little to the imagination, and a low-cut blouse that invited their attention. Although Jen had a-cups, they still couldn't help but imagine how appealing she'd look naked—so tight, so inexperienced.

"Hey, strangers!" Jen exclaimed, completely oblivious to how perverted their intentions were.

"Hey, cutie," Colin teased. "Long time." He was glad to see Jen was unaccompanied, again exchanging lustful and hopeful glances at Wade.

"Where's Jamie?" Wade asked, hoping she might reply in a way to suggest that she's walking a fine line of unfaithfulness, leaving him at home while she visited with two handsome boys.

" Oh, he's out of town."

Damn, they both thought. But that's okay. At least there's no way she'd back out.

"Let's get something to eat," Colin suggested. The trio made their way for the first restaurant they could all agree on.

They spent most of the day at the mall, later returning to Jen's house where they reminisced about the lake house with Jen's parents and watched TV. It was getting late, though, and the two boys could take the hint that they were overstaying their welcome. They left, though they noticed Jen seemed to want them to stay.

"You should sneak out," Colin texted Jen.

Her response seemed to take forever. She was reluctant at first. But eventually, she complied. She sneaked out her window and ran out to the Cul-de-sac, where they had been waiting in Colin's parked car, a dark brown SUV. While the Cul-de-sac was secluded, they decided it'd be best to find another one farther away from Jen's house, so they wouldn't risk being caught by Jen's parents. Plus, they thought it might take a while to get Jen to come around to their seduction.

"So, what are we going to do?" Jen asked, exhilarated to be out past curfew for the first time in her life.

"Drive around a while?" Colin suggested.

They all agreed. They drove around and chatted for a while longer, then, when the moment seemed right, they turned into a subdivision a ways past Jen's, on the other side of the mall, and into a secluded Cul-de-sac not unlike the one besides Jen's house. Colin put the car in park and turned off the ignition. At first, Jen took the parking to be completely innocent, as Colin and Wade began talking to her, just as they had done earlier; she thought Colin was just tired of driving. But then, it was time for them to make their move.

"So Jen, you ever do anything sexual with Jamie?" Colin began.

"Yea, Jen, you ever suck his cock?" Wade teased.

"No, I'm a virgin." She was getting a little nervous, though she couldn't help but wonder what was going to happen. "I'm waiting for marriage."

"Yea, but, Jen. You can't deny that there hasn't been some mutual attraction between the three of us. All those times at my parents' lake house." Colin said.

"I suppose, maybe.... But I'm with Jamie." Her voice began trailing, though her heart began to race, as she got more and more excited as Colin and Wade climbed into the back seat with her. Colin put back the seat, and the two of them began to put their arms around Jen.

"What are you doing?" She faintly asked. But she didn't fight back. She knew she wanted it.

"Come on, Jen, you know you want to wrap your hands around our cocks. We'll teach you."

They lay her back, lying on either side of her. Colin began to kiss her neck, as Wade began to move his hand up her thigh ever so gently.

"No, I'm in a relationship with Jamie... and I'm waiting more marriage." She said again.

"You're going to have to try harder than that. Your acting is terrible, Jen. We know you want it."

She was mute. She didn't up a fight or offer a word of opposition, because she knew if she did she'd be lying. She wanted it.

Colin and Wade both began unzipping their pants and undoing their belts. Either one of them took one of Jen's hands and pushed them down the front of their pants, into their boxers. Jen gasped, growing red. She could feel Wade's cock in her hand, already hard. Colin's was limp, but it started to grow as she wrapped her hand around it and squeezed gently.

"But Jamie..." her voice grew fainter.

"He doesn't have to know," Colin assured her, kissing her neck ever so gently.

She nodded her head, giving them permission. They both pulled down their pants and boxers, giving her better access to both of their cocks. She looked worried, not knowing what to do, both of their cocks in either one of her hands.

"It's okay, Jen," Colin whispered in her ear. "Do Wade first. I'll watch."

"What do I do?" She asked, her face turning red in embarrassment.

"Stroke his cock. Then wrap your lips around his cock and suck on it. Don't be afraid to use your tongue." Colin smiled.

Jen nodded, barely mouthing an, "Okay." She looked over Wade, nervous, not being nearly as acquainted with him as she was with Colin.

"It's okay, baby," Wade tried to ease her mind. "It won't bite."

She started pumping his cock in her hand, and then Wade leaned in and started kissing Jen. She felt her pussy growing moist as they kissed more deeply. Then she felt Colin's hand between her legs, beginning to feel her up rather aggressively and struggling to undo her jean button and zipper. She grew more and more anxious, wondering what Jamie would think.

Wade broke from her kiss and guided her head down toward his cock. She did as Colin had told her, wrapping her lips around his cock, and swirling her tongue around the head of his cock, flicking the tip playfully before taking more of his cock down her throat. Wade moaned, placing his hand on the back of her head and keeping it there as he guided her head on his cock. "Oh, fuck, man. She's a natural." Wade said to Colin. Colin smiled. He had Jen's pants down around her legs now, and was now sliding down her panties. He moved his head between her legs slowly and began to flick his own tongue against her virgin clit.

Jen's eyes widened as her body filled with pleasure. She gagged on Wade's cock as it throbbed in her mouth. She pulled his cock out of her mouth, attempting to voice an opposition. "No, not there. Jamie."

"Jen, you're wet as fuck."

She blushed, submitting to Colin. He began to eat her out. Her moans grew louder as it filled the car. Wade forced her head back down on his cock. She gladly sucked.

"All right, my turn." Colin demanded. They passed Jen around like a bag of Oreos. She moved over to Colin and began sucking his cock just as she had sucked Wade's. Wade picked her backside up and rested her on her knees as she continued to suck Colin's throbbing member. Rubbing his cockhead teasingly against Jen's clit and the lips of her pussy, Wade then pushed his cock slowly inside her. She wanted to fight it, but she submitted. She loved the feeling of Wade's big cock in her tight little pussy. "Oh, Wade," she mouthed, "Oh, Colin," she gagged on his cock.

"That's right, baby, suck that big cock." Colin said.

Wade bucked into Jen's waist from behind, now deep inside her. Colin wanted her pussy now. They turned Jen around, Colin lying on his back, and told her to mount him. She complied, beginning to ride his dick. Wade had helped her out of her blouse, and now completely naked, Colin could admire her tiny tits as they bounced up and down as she rode his dick.

From behind her, Wade was approaching her ass. He was going to have her asshole.

"Wait!" She was surprised as she felt Wade's dickhead against her bottom hole. "Not there!"

"Shh." Wade whispered, "I'll be gentle."

She couldn't resist. She actually wanted to feel what it felt like to have one cock in her pussy while another was in her ass. Wade thrust inward. She yelped. It was so painful. But yet, it hurt so good. "Oh, yes!" She screamed in pleasure. "Fuck me! Make me your slut!" She loved it.

Colin and Wade were gleefully surprised as they both dominated one of her holes. They were both nearing climax. But not yet. They still wanted to accomplish one more thing: the double stuff. They lied her down. She was growing more and more turned on, wondering what was next. She watched as they both stabbed their cocks into her pussy in unison. "Oh, FUCK!" She yelled. It felt amazing. Her pussy felt like it was going to tear, but she had two hot guys' cocks in her at once. She felt like a whore, but at the same time she longed for more. "Oh, yes! Fuck me!" She continued to yell. "Fuck me with those big cocks. Give me the double stuff."

An air of pleasure waved over her as suddenly they felt their cocks drenched in her cum. "Oh yes!" She began to shake on their cocks as she her orgasm overtook her.

"Oh, fuck, I'm gonna cum!" They said in unison.

"Not in there!" She pleaded.

It was the first time they'd caved in to her, as they pulled out and drenched her face in cum.

"Oh, wow," she moaned as she licked her lips clean of cum. "That was wonderful."

The three of them shared a kiss, and they fucked twice more that night before dropping her off at her house. They drove back home and slept their fuck off in the car in a grocery store parking lot. She climbed back into her bedroom window, entirely sexually satisfied. Though, her guilt was weighing on her.

The next morning, she called Jamie and confessed everything, that she had sex with two guys. She couldn't deny that it felt amazing. But she pleaded for him to forgiver her, that "It would never happen again." He rejected her pleas.

"You're a fucking whore!" He said. "And we're over."

But she didn't shed a tear. Instead, she sent a shared text to Colin and Wade's phones. It read: "Hey, when are you two going to take me to pound town again? ;)"

But she was already on the bus, headed for the Colin's parents' lake house in southern Wisconsin. She'd wait for them to arrive and fuck her brains out again and again—because she had indisputably lost Jamie and her purity, too, and all that remained was her undying lust for two cocks at once.

  • Index
  • /
  • Home
  • /
  • Stories Hub
  • /
  • Group Sex
  • /
  • The Good Ones Are Always Bad

All contents © Copyright 1996-2023. Literotica is a registered trademark.

Desktop versionT.O.S.PrivacyReport a ProblemSupport

Version ⁨1.0.2+795cd7d.adb84bd⁩

We are testing a new version of this page. It was made in 501 milliseconds